Montclair 5 Stars Hotels

"Dining is great"

"Our stay at The Beekman was great. The best part is the on site dining options. The Bar Room is stunning and has a great vibe. Be sure to make reservations if you are visiting in the evening on weekends. The bell staff are especially friendly. The only complaint would be that there is no self serve water in the lobby and twice during our stay the coffee was empty (no in room coffee available). Also, turn down service was only offered for part of our stay. "

"The check in person was CRAZY aggressive trying to upsell me $500/night for a suite. There was some strange noise in the wall from midnight to 3am. Like a cell phone was buried in the wall or something. buzzing/vibration. The bell staff were very nice. LOVED the giant family room."

"Great stay "

"Excellent home to home "

"Great service. Everyone was so welcoming. "

"The location and the friendliness of the stafff "

"Beautiful hotel with incredible service, spacious rooms, excellent fitness center, and in a great location! I highly recommend this hotel in NYC!"

"We chose the St.Regis for its famous lobby and bar and classic charm. We were not told until just before our arrival that the lobby was being renovated and off limits and the bar and restaurant were closed. We understand those are being modernized and the beautiful rooms will also be modernized. Exactly what we do not want, so we will not return."

"Pros: Spacious and clean room. Fantastic views of the Hudson River and NYC skyline. Convenient location close to Central Park, Lincoln Center, Carnegie Hall, shopping and great restaurants. Lovely staff. Cons: none "

"Only two words for the Carlyle: THE BEST."

"Great hotel, but the quality of service doesn’t meet the standard it should for a premier hotel"

"👍"

"Very nice"

"I love the perfume was used all inside the lobby and entrance. Breakfast area was fantastic. Highly recommend. Very clean, friendly, helpful and very polite people."

"Fabulous "

"Fantastic hotel. Beautiful, clean, and staffed with very friendly and competent people. Will definitely come back! One small nit: Many cable stations were out in my room. So I had to give up MSNBC for three nights and resort to CNN and a smattering of ABC news. It probably for was for own good;)"

"Beautiful hotel, beautiful room and amenities , very clean and quiet. The staff was so friendly, courteous, and helpful. 10 out of 10 in all categories!"

"Expensive but worth it. Two adults & 2 younger kids. We got a one bedroom suite that was HUGE. Most of the reasonably priced rooms in the city are the size of shoe boxes. NOTE: though they list that the room sleeps 4 , it doesn’t without rollaways. But the rooms are so big that the rollaways fit no problem. Bed was comfy. Room was quiet-never heard neighbors above, below, or to the sides. Usual NYC noise on the street at all hours but not bad with a white noise machine. Ask for a higher...

"Very convenient to theaters. Team of employees courteous and helpful."