Find Historic Hotels in City Island, NY

"Very central. Busy hotel but very nice and clean. Its NY so there is good food everywhere. It was walkable and easy to reach other areas. The room was nice Small bathroom but okay for a few days and clean with a good shower. The couch is convenient if you need to get some work done or need a little extra space. "

"The location is prime The elevator needs help "

"Great location. Spacious and comfortable room. Friendly staff."

"Awesome "

"Loved it"

"The location, and very friendly"

"My family and I had a truly wonderful experience during our stay at the New Yorker Hotel. From the moment we arrived, we were impressed by the hotel’s classic charm, cleanliness, and overall atmosphere. The rooms were spotless, well-maintained, and offered a comfortable place to relax after a day of exploring the city. One of the standout features of this hotel is its unbeatable location. We were within walking distance of iconic landmarks such as Times Square and the Empire State Building, which made it incredibly convenient for sightseeing. Being so centrally located also meant easy access to public transportation, restaurants, and entertainment options. The staff were professional and courteous, always ready to assist with a smile. It’s clear that the hotel is well-managed and committed to providing a high-quality guest experience. Overall, our stay at the New Yorker Hotel exceeded our expectations. I would highly recommend it to anyone visiting New York City, whether for a family vacation or a quick weekend getaway. "

"If you are looking for an authenticly New York City experience then this is the place to stay! I don't usually write reviews, but the staff at the Hotel St. James clearly take pride in what they do and deserve to be recognized for it! From the maintenance and up keep of this historical building to the overall cleanliness of the rooms and the friendliness of the front desk clerks (with the most NYC accents you've ever heard), it's clear they know what they are doing at this adorable hotel. All of this on top of the affordable prices and the unbeatable location in the heart of Times Square make it the best place in NYC to stay in my personal opinion!"

"Location was amazing! Helpful and friendly staff. Great value."