City Island 4 Stars Hotels

"First off I want to say I was somewhat cautious due to the overwhelming theme of reviews being negative due to long elevator times. I did not experience this whatsoever. I’ve been to NYC countless times and always stay in a similar hotel (doubletree, Hilton garden inn, etc) and the elevators are no different than really any other hotel in the city. If you’ve been to NYC before, you know what to expect. It’s a crowded city and yes you may have to wait for almost anything. But I had zero issue with the elevators and I feel like it is truly a non issue, certainly not worth a bad or negative review. The location is excellent with close access to the 4,5 train, the R, W train, and to the 1 train not to mention the Staten Island ferry. Decent food options near by and a Duane Reade on the corner which is a NYC must. The room was nice, clean, everything worked as it should. Most of the time in NYC, you’re only at the room to sleep, shower, and nap. "

"Fantastic room, staff, location and amenities, but very expensive!!"

"While the hotel is older amd may not have the newer ammenities, the distance was perfect. Staff was nice. "

"Wonderful services everyone very accommodating and friendly!"

"Clean room , great staff "

"The staff from the moment we walked in were so friendly and ensuredcthey coukd help.us arrange a driver on the morning of our departure. The two bellmen were amazing! "

"My favorite hotel in NY! I will always stay here no matter what! The staff is amazing and they always treat me like family. I truly love it here."

"Staff were very nice. Lines were long but moved quickly. Room was very clean. The room was small but as expected for midtown. Location was excellent, only steps to Times Square and shows. "

"Check in and lobby staff were very nice, professional, and helpful. The room was small and clean. The beds were very creaky but comfortable. It was quite warm in the room and we could not turn the temperature down at all. We were on the second floor and it was a little noisy outside the room until about midnight. "