Preferred Fire Island hotels

"Friendliest staff"

"Clean and efficient. Loved the hot tea options and yogurt and fruit. Would have liked more fruit and yogurt options"

"My stay was nice the staff was great the room was spotless amenities excellent. What stood out just some maintenance issues. My bathroom door didn't close unless I lifted it because the hinges were loose and the closet doors where were hard to slide back and forth. But the bed was excellent and again the room and staff were great."

"Staff was amazing and the room was perfect, so clean. I especially loved the bathroom, it was so bright, it made me want to redo my bathroom at home. And the parking was so quick and the gentleman so polite. Absolutely wonderful experience."

"Comfortable and cozy "

"Staff and cleanliness are great"

"Staff makes your stay perfect as possible always friendly."

"Yes"

"My family all lives in Nassau county, it’s hard to find a decent hotel sometimes We always pick the LBH and it doesn’t disappoint "