The room was ancient. The windows were 'jalousie' style (louvred) - which means zero sound / climate insulation - worse than single pane (looked like they were from the 50s). You could hear everything outside (they even provided earplugs, which is a sign). I had to crank the heater up to offset the cold air (this was January). The bed had just an ultra-light blanket, and I was cold the whole night (there was an extra blanket in the closet but I'm not too keen on using those - not sure how often they are cleaned). The front door was split 'Dutch style' which meant there was a gap and no insulation.
The floor felt like it could collapse at any moment (I was on the 2nd floor). This place really is a relic from the past, and feels like it hasn't been updated in decades. Parking is free but was very tight - practice your uphill reversing skills! For 'breakfast' a basket is left outside your room with some OJ, bagel, toast, yoghurt, and fruit. Since it's left outside, I hope they don't recycle the contents but as I only ate one item (a cold bagel), it's a terrible waste.
The hotel location is fantastic - steps from Ocean Ave, which is ideal - no need to drive anywhere as you can reach the shops/restaurant in seconds and the beach in minutes. The price was reasonable for the location. I can only imagine the high rating is because of location and price.