Highgate Independent Randall's Island hotels

"The hotel is showing signs of wear and neglect. It clearly underwent a facelift a few past, the materials used and installed were not designed to last. Small items were also unaddressed, like we did not have enough towels. In the end it was expensive for the conditions. The location is great."

"Area close to all the attractions!!"

"The hotel is in a perfect spot in the city"

"The moment I walked in staff informed me that they never offered valet services, and two minutes later a valet showed up. Our room smelled like mold and the bathroom had a strong urine odor. Ohhh not to mention the clogged tub! We had a terrible experience at the Hyatt Hotel."

"Just a very old run down hotel "

"The hotel is across the street from the Barrymore Theater. "

"Great location! Great city!"

"I was expecting this hotel to be awful bc it was inexpensive but it was clean and much more spacious than regular nyc hotels. It’s olddd but excellent location!! I’d def stay again. It’s one of the least expensive options and so convenient "

"Had no inconvenience and great location"