Highgate Independent Plum Island hotels

"Staff was great, great location"

"Would stay again"

" Staff is great. Cleanliness great. Bars great. Ambiance great. Views amazing. The only negative were the room's fearures wasn't working. My initial room had sheer drapes that didn't open. 2nd room has lights that didn't work. 3rd room was good until a few hours in. The sheer drapes didn't close. But I understand things malfunction. The hotel was very accommodating. I will visit again. "

"The elevator capacity is inadequate to the extreme. Need to be able to handle morning rush common to New York events. I won’t be coming back to this disaster again."

"This is my second stay at this particular hotel. Everything was good. Definitely will be staying there again."

"The property was under renovations, which we appreciate, but it caused some common spaces to be unusable and extra time to wait on elevators, etc while workers were using elevators to move materials. Our room was newly renovated and felt very clean. We love the location. It was a great experience."

"Small rooms but ok for the price. bathtub very slippery- hazard. Towels were so so- it is an ok place nothing special."

"Love the Renwick! Ideally located two blocks from Grand Central, 15 minute walk to Bryant Park and 30 minute walk to MoMA and Theatre District. Staff are great, it’s clean and modern. Plus there’s a fun bar attached to it for a nightcap. "

"Great location! Easy to get to everything. Clean hotel, friendly staff."