Find Golf Hotels in Menantic Creek, NY

"Lovely short stay! Right on the beautiful beach. Staff were so welcoming and even quickly sent me something I accidentally left behind in the room. Absolutely plan to be back!"

"Quaint hotel in town. It’s perfect!"

"Good property, centrally located near both Montauk and East Hampton."

"Highly recommend!"

"OK. I don't typically write effusive reviews...or write many online ratings. When I do, it's because the service or product is exceptional (and in rare cases, abysmal). I was born and lived in the "Hamptons" as a boy and a teenager. I returned to show my family where I grew up. I last visited the area 35 years ago in this rare and beautiful place on the South Fork of Long Island. A flood of boyhood memories were augmented and complemented by the Hampton's Vacation Inn. Dayan made everything easy and seamless because she was personally responsive. The easily accessible and convenient property and cottages provide a quiet pastoral environment within the activity that is "The Hamptons" with Stop & Shop literally across Montauk Highway (though we couldn't tell the 2-lane "highway" was just yards away) and Classic Beverage adjacent. Multiple dining and shopping options are readily available and within easy walking distance. We recommend Dero's supervised by Air Force veteran Paul who is the patriarch of the family restaurant business. Our 2 BR quiet cottage was clean, comfy, cozy, welcoming and well-equipped. Hampton's Vacation Inn quietly demands that you power down, relax and enjoy this magical place."

"Nice views and very comfortable"

"Loved it"

"Amazing resort, very friendly staff, food and drinks are Amazing! We enjoyed our stay. "

"Shelter Island is definitely a gem"