"The furniture was top notch and the collectables impressive for a place 200 years old.
Ron was pleasant and informative.
All in all, the best place we've ever stayed!++"
"The furniture was top notch and the collectables impressive for a place 200 years old.
Ron was pleasant and informative.
All in all, the best place we've ever stayed!++"
"Loved our stay at Wishmaker B&B. All the staff were amazing, especially Kate. She was very helpful in planning our day. The breakfast setup was very nice and we didn’t have to decide what to eat, the menu changed each morning. The dinner was awesome and the cheesecake- I could go on for hours about the cheesecake. An entire cheesecake menu. Our favorite was the Autumn special cheesecake.
Will definitely return to see the Christmas season decor and cheesecake winter special"
"Loved our stay at Wishmaker B&B. All the staff were amazing, especially Kate. She was very helpful in planning our day. The breakfast setup was very nice and we didn’t have to decide what to eat, the menu changed each morning. The dinner was awesome and the cheesecake- I could go on for hours about the cheesecake. An entire cheesecake menu. Our favorite was the Autumn special cheesecake.
Will definitely return to see the Christmas season decor and cheesecake winter special"
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
It was great! We were in Columbus for a concert and decided to stay in the city for the night. We were within walking distance of food and our concert venue, which made it so much easier to navigate the city. We got back to our room around midnight, and never felt unsafe during our walk back.
The innkeeper was very kind and accommodating for us. The house was absolutely beautiful and well-kept. We were on the third floor, so keep in mind if you're staying during a super hot week, heat rises. We...
It was great! We were in Columbus for a concert and decided to stay in the city for the night. We were within walking distance of food and our concert venue, which made it so much easier to navigate the city. We got back to our room around midnight, and never felt unsafe during our walk back.
The innkeeper was very kind and accommodating for us. The house was absolutely beautiful and well-kept. We were on the third floor, so keep in mind if you're staying during a super hot week, heat rises. We...
Loved our stay at Wishmaker B&B. All the staff were amazing, especially Kate. She was very helpful in planning our day. The breakfast setup was very nice and we didn’t have to decide what to eat, the menu changed each morning. The dinner was awesome and the cheesecake- I could go on for hours about the cheesecake. An entire cheesecake menu. Our favorite was the Autumn special cheesecake.
Will definitely return to see the Christmas season decor and cheesecake winter special
Loved our stay at Wishmaker B&B. All the staff were amazing, especially Kate. She was very helpful in planning our day. The breakfast setup was very nice and we didn’t have to decide what to eat, the menu changed each morning. The dinner was awesome and the cheesecake- I could go on for hours about the cheesecake. An entire cheesecake menu. Our favorite was the Autumn special cheesecake.
Will definitely return to see the Christmas season decor and cheesecake winter special
Jeffrey
Reviewed November 3, 2026Reviewed November 3, 2026
This was an excellent place to stay! My wife and I drove down from Cleveland to do some antiquing before New Years Eve and it is in a perfect location. This historical home is very well maintained and the attention to detail is fantastic. The bed was amazing and slept better here than we did at home! Ron, the owner, was a pleasure to have conversations with throughout our stay. He truly is a genuine man and could not have asked for a better stay. Will plan to stay again in the summer. Thank you...
This was an excellent place to stay! My wife and I drove down from Cleveland to do some antiquing before New Years Eve and it is in a perfect location. This historical home is very well maintained and the attention to detail is fantastic. The bed was amazing and slept better here than we did at home! Ron, the owner, was a pleasure to have conversations with throughout our stay. He truly is a genuine man and could not have asked for a better stay. Will plan to stay again in the summer. Thank you...