I tend to judge hotels based on whether they are letting things go, like upkeeping the gym equipment and pool. Sure enough, this one had the pool closed (for repairs?), one of three cardio machines out of order, missing a 5lb and 10lb weight, no extra gym towels, no water container in the gym, and no wipes for cleaning the equipment. The gym is probably the lowest priority, but it doesn't take much effort to think about details guests might care about. I'd only pick this place again for the convenient location to visit Reading, but I'd keep my expectations low.