Top Vacation Homes in Central Eleuthera in 2026

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Top cities in Central Eleuthera

A church with a bell tower, green shutters, and a cross on top.

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Our top choices for Central Eleuthera vacation homes

A room with two blue armchairs, a white round table, and a view of the sea through large glass doors.

1. Ocean Shire 2 Bedroom Home

Rainbow Bay

A sandy beach with palm trees and a clear blue sky.

2. Winfield Manor 3 Bedroom Home

Governor's Harbour

A beachfront property with a pool house, multiple guest houses, and driveways.

3. Bohemia Bungalows

Governor's Harbour

A beach with clear turquoise water, palm trees, and a thatched umbrella.

4. Key Lime Cottage 2 Bedroom Home

Rainbow Bay

A clear turquoise sea with visible underwater rocks and a rocky shoreline.

5. Paradise Cove 3 Bedroom Home

Gregory Town

A large, symmetrical building with a central circular fountain, surrounded by manicured gardens and a clear sky.

6. Eagle Ray - Brand New Beach Cottage W/views, Walk To Restaurant/ 2 Bedroom Home

North Palmetto Point

A beach with clear turquoise water, a sandy shore, and rocky formations in the distance.

7. Rocks Retreat 2 Bedroom Home

North Palmetto Point

8. Sandy Hill Beach House by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Governor's Harbour

A pool area with a view of the ocean, surrounded by lush greenery and a white building with green shutters.

9. Buccaneer Hill Main House 5 Bedroom Home

Governor's Harbour

10. Alfred House & Cottage by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Governor's Harbour

View all properties

Top reviews in Central Eleuthera

A beach with a thatched roof structure, sandy beach, and clear blue ocean.

Pineapple Fields Boutique Condo Hotel

Governor's Harbour

10/10 Excellent

Randi

A poolside area with lounge chairs and umbrellas, overlooking a clear blue sea and a distant island.

French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection

Governor's Harbour

10/10 Excellent

perfect type of vacation of you want to get away and relax...its certainty quieter than say a Nassau vacation but very enjoyable. the room are individual bungalows. there arent many, perhaps 20 or so and most looked brand new. our room had a direct view to the ocean (Caribbean side)..the beach is on the Atlantic side. they provide you with a golf cart to ride around the resort and to/from the beach. restaurant was good quality and many healthy options. staff was very friendly. the gave plenty of...

Chris

A marina with several yachts docked at wooden piers.

Spanish Wells Yacht Haven

Spanish Wells

10/10 Excellent

Jeffrey

A wooden deck with a table and chairs, overlooking a lush landscape and a body of water.

Villa Allamanda

Governor's Harbour

10/10 Excellent

John is an amazing person and very warm host who went above and beyond to make sure our needs were met. From taking us into town on our first night for some groceries to giving us a lift to the nearest beach. He also directed us to a friend who we were able to rent a great car from. The hotel itself was well equipped and very thought-out. There was a nook for every need, an outlet at every corner, lights galore. Both the interior and exterior of the house are colorful and true to the spirit of...

Daria

A beach with palm trees and a staircase leading to a beach area.

La Bougainvillea Hotel and Villas

North Palmetto Point

10/10 Excellent

La Bougainvillea was a random choice, but we are so happy we chose to stay there. It is a relatively new venture with an eye for detail and and an engaging staff. The location is mid-point on Eleuthera and the beach is absolutely spectacular. If you are looking to get off the grid and unwind, this is the spot. We'd start each morning with a walk along the 2 mile beach and swim. The sand is amazing...clean, like "walking on marshmallows"...can we trademark that citation? A steady breeze...

Jim

A wooden deck with wicker furniture and a view of the ocean.

Coral Sands Inn & Cottages

Dunmore Town

10/10 Excellent

We couldn't have had a better time. The Manager, Pamela Berry, greeted us upon arrival (10 AM) and since the Jr Suite we were getting was not occupied, allowed us into the room early. They also arranged for a golf cart to be delivered to the property(a must!) We quickly unpacked and got to the beach and walked to the coral and back. Dora at the beach was very accommodating and was able to get us towels, drinks and all our water sports. The food was great and what you would expect at an upscale...

Scott

A covered outdoor seating area with a pool, overlooking a beach and ocean.

The Cove Eleuthera

Gregory Town

10/10 Excellent

kevin

A beach with white sand, clear blue water, and several blue umbrellas.

Tingum Village Hotel

Dunmore Town

10/10 Excellent

Our second stay at Tingum Village, our first one was perfect and we had to return. Rooms are spacious, bathrooms are nice, and each room as its own unique island décor. The staff that runs the place, let me rephrase that statement, an amazing charismatic family operates this hotel and they will do anything for their guests to feel like family. Not the typical “Anything” as the obvious like fresh towels and hot coffee our “anything” experience is well behind that typical “anything”. Our...

George