Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY

"Stellar staff who made us feel most welcome. Loved the diversity of the team. Unforgettable scenery and experiences. We will definitely come back!"

"Parking was easy, but this place is kind of creepy. There are signs for human trafficking everywhere. "

"They charged us for parking in front of our room. Unbelievable. We stayed there in April, off season, the motel was empty."

"Perfect for 1 night stay. Staff communicated perfectly."

"Great views from the restaurant and bar area. Staff were very friendly and attentive. Will stay here again."

"The breakfast was delicious, the rooms were nice, and the bar was perfect. In all of my travels I think the staff at this hotel might be the nicest, most accommodating people I’ve ever met. They truly made our stay wonderful. Olga and the other front desk staff were amazing. "

"It was a good experience in general, definitely recommend and I would go back if I need to"

"Unhinged wacko"

"The rooms were clean. The bathroom had a pocket door for the toilet area that did not close properly and the lock did not work. The shower was outside the toilet area, but there was no door only a curtain."