Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island Heights, NY

"The rooms were super clean,comfortable and inviting! Would definitely stay again!"

"Great location. Affordable option to visit Mystic, CT"

"Loved everything about this property. Location, Staff, Amenities. Decor and furniture beautiful. "

"Great staff. The front desk man quickly changed our room when my husband noted it would benoisy, being by the elevator and ice machine. He's a light sleeper, especially bothered by noise. The breakfast room attendent was the most attentive I've ever seen. Kept the eggs and sausages coming, piping hot, and wiped down the tables immediately. "

"Locations are d writhing, and the marran has this, right on the beach, watching whales, dolphins and spinning sharks from the comfort of the pool and/or beach…… lovely sitting area for drinks and dinner watching the sun go down. This is a hotel to savour on a nice night, we stayed the 18/19 sept, 2025! One thing that was a shock, no TV in room and little hanging space for clothes, so if you can manage around that (as we did) The other odd point and the reason for my low score on Eco friendly, is the hotels use of plastic fork, knives and spoons, and plastic cups which in this day goes against the grain, so that aside if you want a modern hotel in a great location thus is a must……. And one, that we would go back too."

"Super friendly staff! Rooms and grounds were much nicer than I was expecting absolutely best value! "

"Wonderful hotel and location "

"Clean and beautiful view"

"Loved it"