Find Historic Hotels in Newcastle, WY

"We loved our 2 night stay. The room was pleasant, along with the rest of the property. We did not use the pool. The breakfast was great! It was nice to see breakfast staffed to make sure everything was available. The staff was great! Our only disappointment was the soft bed. We were sinking to the middle of the bed. May be time to replace the mattress."

"Clean. Outside could use a new paint job but inside was clean, however the ac was making a funny noise but stayed cold. When I pulled the shower handle the spout came in and out of the wall. It wasn't secured. Needs a little love and we did have a centipede in the room one night but fortunately we saw it before we stepped on it! "

"Lovely place. Many nice touches. Very child friendly. Close to Crazy Horse Memorial which is a must see. "

"The cabin was overall clean and centrally located. We had an issue with dirty bedding but the staff took care of the problem. We had the end 6 plex cabins and you could hear traffic noise while in the cabin which was not a major issue but something to be aware of if you select those cabins. "

"Arrived fine, but found the office hard to locate at first. Cabin was great. Would have been good to better understand the cabin view before I booked but the sound was distant from traffic so ok. Parking was first come, first serve, but didn't pose a problem for us. The description said it included breakfast, but it was muffins, etc -- a to go meal only. Very clean, and we liked the deck very much for a quiet sit after sight seeing!"

"Great location . Very clean . "

"Second time staying here and this is just the place to stay when in the Black Hills. Gorgeous views and vibes. Friendly staff and all the amenities when traveling with young children. "

"Great staff, clean room, pretty quiet and nice location. "

"It was a straightforward and budget friendly hotel. Downtown Custer was all within walking distance. "