Find hotels in Menantic Creek, Shelter Island

"Lovely hotel. Amazing location. Gorgeous views. Breakfast was good continental. It rained hard and we had some water leaking in the door from the back deck. Mentioned it to the front desk when we checked out. Could’ve posed a Could’ve posed a slipping hazard.Otherwise, I would’ve given five stars. "

"Clean, spacious and thoughtful room amenities. Close by to town and great restaurants. "

"Very pleasurable experience here. It’s not something we’ll do every year, as it is expensive. Spa services are especially expensive. Nonetheless, the staf performed flawlessly. Food was excellent. Grounds were well cared for."

"We booked this hotel for the indoor pool so the kids can spend their time swimming, upon arrival we were asked if we received a call that the pool will be closed due to maintenance(which we did not)This was extremely frustrating as the pool was the reason that we booked the hotel. They offered to remove the resort fee from our reservation but during checkout they tried to charge it again. It was extremely hard to get the personnel to turn on the firepits or deliver anything to our room. I understand it is off season but if you cannot operate on the level of service a good hotel is supposed to operate do not keep it open"

"Great property"

"Loud room was what it looked like in the pics. Cold "

"I did see a couple with 2 dogs lol"

"Room was not clean sheets were dirty with hairs in them they let me switch rooms and the other room was fine "

"The Journey is always pleasant. Only issue I have regards buisness travelers....no desk in the rooms."