We were very comfortable at The Hoxton. The rooms are lovely, quiet and cozy. The food and service at the dinette is excellent. It's easy to get around downtown LA on foot, via uber, or by metro. We didn't have a car during our stay, so I can't speak to valet service.
Especially given the price of rooms, I wish the rooftop pool had longer hours. It's closed before sunset in the summer, which is unfortunate. The rooms don't have closets and could benefit from luggage racks.