The Best Historic Hotels in Fishers Island, NY from NT$6,298 in 2026

A calm lake with several boats anchored in the distance, surrounded by grassy banks and a rocky shoreline.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on Fishers Island Historic Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for Fishers Island historic hotels

Standard Double Room, 2 Double Beds | Blackout drapes, soundproofing, iron/ironing board, WiFi (free)

Deluxe Room, 1 Queen Bed | Blackout drapes, soundproofing, iron/ironing board, WiFi (free)

1. The Taber Inne & Suites

Mystic

Heather

NT$5,477

NT$6,298 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 23 - Sep 24

2 restaurants; breakfast, lunch, and dinner served

2. The Spa at Norwich Inn

Norwich

Amy

NT$5,551

NT$6,894 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 27 - Sep 28

View all properties

Top Fishers Island Hotel Reviews

Best Western Mystic Hotel

8/10 Good

"Clean and quiet hotel for a one night stay. Nothing fancy but the room was spotless and the bed was comfortable. Coffee in the room and in the lobby. Breakfast buffet had all the basics. Desk staff helpful. I would stay there again."

Spark by Hilton Mystic Groton

10/10 Excellent

"The room was really nice and we felt safe"

Regency Inn & Suites New London, Mystic

10/10 Excellent

"The clean room the staff was nice"

Frequently asked questions

What can a history buff expect from a stay in Fishers Island?

You're already probably planning a visit to places with historical relevance while you're staying in Fishers Island. Also discover the many sights including the shopping and restaurants

What are the must-see historical sites and other places in Fishers Island?

A favorite place to visit is South Beach. In the area, you'll also find Foxwoods Resort Casino and Mohegan Sun Casino.

What is a historic hotel like in Fishers Island?

Guests who choose a historic hotel can sleep in a building that has an officially recognized national historic designation. A castle, stately home, palace or even a pub, lodge, old police station, or skyscraper can be considered a historic hotel provided that it's of special interest. Traditional architecture and period features are typically found in the public spaces and guestrooms of historic hotels in Fishers Island, giving a sense of history.

What is the difference between a historic hotel and a heritage hotel?

"Heritage hotel" is a term often used in Asia and Europe, wheareas the term "historic hotel" is more commonly used in the U.S. overall though the terms are similar. The physical building and architecture of a historic hotel is generally the most significant aspect. For a heritage hotel, often it's the cultural value along with how it inspired the community.

Do historic hotels in Fishers Island have modern facilities?

Hotel interiors feature the modern conveniences and safety features you expect to find, while every effort is made to preserve the historic aspects and traditions. Smart TVs, WiFi, updated bathroom facilities, and the popular amenities found in any hotel will also be available in a historic hotel. Rest assured that when you select a historic hotel in Fishers Island, you won't find yourself staying at a place that is rundown or uncomfortable.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Book Historic Hotels in Fishers Island on Expedia.com

Find Historic Hotels in Fishers Island, NY

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky