Find Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island Pines, NY

"I would not recommend this place. Our room had a hole in the shower wall. A metal box in the shower. There was some stuff that was disguising on the frame of the door. Carpet was worn and torn. Near the air the floor was very wet. I went to the front desk, and he said they will be renovating the place. This is the worse place I ever stayed in. "

"Staff very helpful "

"Lounge staff was incredibly helpful and supportive in every aspect. "

"The room was comfortable and the staff was very friendly. The shower did not get quite as hot as I would have liked and the jacuzzi was out of order. The pool and gym were very good and the restaurant was lovely until late."

"This property is very dilapidated and could use a lot of renovations. First room we got, the tv wasn’t working. The 2nd room had some kind of stain in the corner and smelled like smoke. Some of the ceiling tiles were out of place, but at that point, we were too tired to be moved again. I spoke with another guest whose first room was already occupied and they walked in to a naked man and their second room had a large blood stain on the rug. First time here and definitely the last time."

"My stay was amazing and the complementary breakfast was a plus! Thank you for the great hospitality by the front desk too. "

"Very nice place to stay when in the area. Consistently good. It’s quiet, clean, and yea consistent. Breakfast is okay (typical Marriott) eggs, sausage, fruit yogurt, and oatmeal. The staff are all very friendly and accommodating."

"Front desk check in was quick and staff very friendly. The road noise was a bit much for me while trying to get to sleep but, if you live in a city I'm sure it wouldn't be a big deal. Overall, good experience."

"Staff was helpful when i needed to extend my stay"