Find Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

" We stayed here for one night. Property was nice and clean. We got to breakfast about 15 minutes before closing and there wasn’t much left so get there early. "

"I frequently stay at this hotel. On my last stay, I found socks in the bed. This time, there was terrible water pressure. I love the staff at this hotel. They are welcoming, professional and always courteous. But the prices have gone up and the last few issues (socks and water pressure) have me thinking I need to find a new hotel in that area."

"Clean, courteous"

"I like the hotel because it safe, the staff there are very nice Furthermore, the location is close to everything. "

"Great place, conveniently located close to the LIE, supermarket, restaurants, and local attractions. I was on the island from New Jersey visiting lighthouses and Sagamore Hill NHS, which was very close by. Clean and modern rooms, comfy beds, friendly staff. Heather at the front desk was very friendly and helpful. Will stop by again if I’m in the area. "

"nice and clean."

"A lovely location, staff is amazing, very quiet, relaxing stay in between work assignments."

"G"

"So convenient. Quiet & very clean"