Find Beach Hotels in Fire Island, NY

"Upon arrival at the Red Roof Inn, the reception staff was not very friendly, and we had to wait for our room to be ready. Unfortunately, our experience did not improve afterward. The cleaning staff was rude to my wife when she asked about the lack of trash cans in the room. The staff member responded in a dismissive and rude tone, saying it was impossible because she was sure one had been placed there. Another member of the cleaning staff later came by to verify and confirmed there was indeed no trash can, and then brought one for us. Additionally, the elevator was in very poor condition. It looked and felt more like a cargo elevator rather than one intended for guests. Overall, the experience was disappointing and did not meet basic expectations for comfort and service."

"Yes"

"I did not use the laundry service. The gym was excellent. "

"No WiFi "

"It’s a beautiful property where the rooms are kept very clean. The bar and restaurant are terrific. The bar was opened until 1am on the weekends. The big downside was all the stains on chairs and couches. It looks ewww and I didn’t want to sit on any of that. Quite gross. Otherwise everything was great "

"The hot tub was closed at 10pm on a Friday which was unfortunate."

"Didn’t make up the room when asked "

"I choose this hotel above others in the area that were less expensive because they said they had 24/7 food available. They did not. The staff stood directly beneath the sign on their wall that said "24/7 food available" and said the kitchen closed at 7. I asked another staff member why they didn't have food available and she just shrugged. I'm assuming it is a question they get a lot: I saw a family leaving the next day complaining they had to go to a different hotel to get dinner. "

"Doorkey took 3-4 trips back to front desk to actually work. So very frustrating! No phone charging ports which in this day and age is unbelievable!! The worst and most disappointing thing were the rude people in the next room were so loud and obnoxious waking us up. Won’t be coming back. "