Independent Florida Keys hotels

"This place is wonderful. Especially the staff. Delightful personnel that make you feel like you’re at home. A must stay when visiting this area. "

"September is the quietest month and this has been exceptionally quiet apparently, still staff were very attentive, no reason to think it unusual ,"

"The staff were friendly and funny. The room was comfortable. I had fun. "

"Stayed here on a whim because the price was great for a night. My partner and I loved our little weekend getaway. Everything was fantastic, really clean, great friendly staff, big room, really comfortable overall. The location is halfway into the Florida Keys, so it's great if you want to stay there or drive about an hour down to Key West. We loved it, definitely recommend. "

"We have stayed here before and it is a great set up! Wonderful view of the water traffic! "

"Excellent recommendation for a small budget."

"Loved the stay at Amara Cay! Will be back. Staff was amazing."

"Great location. Very nice and quiet 🤐 "

"Great facility, great beach, friendly staff. Just wish rooms were cleaner (need a lot of vacuuming/dusting) "