Photo by Evgeniy Kolesnikov
Find Historic Hotels in Fire Island, NY
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check availability on Fire Island Historic Hotels
Our top choices for Fire Island historic hotels
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (655 reviews)
"Beautiful grounds and castle. Really cool experience to stay in a castle that has so much history on long island. Friendly staff, clean rooms, and an awesome restaurant/bar."
Charles
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Top Fire Island Hotel Reviews
Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island by IHG
10/10 Excellent
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
- Luxury Hotels in Hauppauge
- Cabin Rentals in Long Island
- Adventure Hotels in Long Island
- Golf Hotels in Central Islip
- Pet-Friendly Hotels in Patchogue
- La Quinta Inn & Suites Hotels in Bayport
- 5 Star Hotels in Davis Park
- Hotels near Bethpage Ballpark
- Romantic Hotels in Long Island
- Cherry Grove Hotels
- Historic Hotels in Long Island
- Adults Only Resorts & in Fire Island
- Hotels near Central Islip Station
- 4 Star Hotels in Bay Shore
- Hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse
- Hotels with an Indoor Pool in Long Island
- Gay friendly Hotels in Sayville
- Family Hotels in Fire Island
- Beach Hotels in Long Island
- Cheap Hotels in Bay Shore
- Hotels with smoking rooms in Long Island
- Beach Hotels in Hauppauge
- Winery Hotels in Long Island
- Bohemia Hotels
- 4 Star Hotels in Islip
- Resorts & Hotels with Spas in Long Island
- Historic Hotels in Bay Shore
- Adults Only Resorts & in Long Island
- 3 Star Hotels in Bay Shore
- 4 Star Hotels in West Bay Shore
- Family Hotels in Medford
- Hotels with a Pool in Farmingville
- Gay friendly Hotels in Lindenhurst
- Motels in Sayville
- East Islip Hotels
- Hotels near Robert Moses State Park
- Hotels with a Pool in Holtsville
- Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island
- Pet-Friendly Hotels in Central Islip
- Romantic Hotels in Holtsville
- Luxury Hotels in Brentwood
- Hotels with a Pool in Brentwood
- Hotels near Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal
- Hotels with Free Parking in Long Island
- 4 Star Hotels in Central Islip
- Hotels with a Pool in Central Islip
- Motels in Bohemia
- Ocean Beach Hotels
- Family Hotels in Copiague
- Visit Islip
- Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal
- Visit Bohemia
- Connetquot River State Park
- Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park
- Visit Ocean Bay Park
- Great South Bay
- Sailors' Haven
- Richard L. Brooks Memorial Park
- Visit Brightwaters
- Bay Shore Mini Golf
- Fire Island Lighthouse
- Visit Babylon
- Visit Fire Island
- Ocean Beach Vacations
- Bohemia Vacations
- Heckscher State Park
- Kismet Vacations
- Visit Fire Island Pines
- Robert Moses State Park
- Cohalan Court Complex
- Visit Blue Point
- Shorefront Park
- Visit Long Island
- Visit Cherry Grove
- Visit Oak Beach
- Payless Rental Cars in East Islip
- Car rental Bohemia
- Avis Rental Cars in MacArthur
- Budget Rental Cars in Islip
- Thrifty Car Rental Rental Cars in Oak Beach
- Europcar Rental Cars in Fire Island
- Avis Rental Cars in Great River
- Car rentals near Touro College School of Health Sciences
- Car rental Bay Shore
- Hertz Rental Cars in Long Island
- Drive on Holidays Rental Cars in Fire Island Pines
- Car rentals near Sagtikos Manor