East Garden City Vacation Rentals

"Was a wonderful experience "

"The air conditioning in our room didn’t work, even after we requested a change. When we checked again later, they claimed to have an issue with the HVAC system. However, instead of acknowledging the problem, they offered us an alternate room. The room we were given was only partially cleaned, and we found a pin and some tablets in the carpet, along with hair on the chairs. Overall, it was a disappointing experience."

"Breakfast was good and very close to stadium"

"Perfect location, amazing food and service."

"Nice apartments. There are not enough parking spots but the rest is good."

"This was the cheapest hotel I could find in Manhattan that wasn’t a shared room hostel. Pros - It’s on the cheaper side by Manhattan standards (but by any other standards extremely expensive for what it is!) The location is fantastic. One block away from a subway station with multiple lines. Walkable to Times Square, Rockerfeller and Grand Central. Even walkable to Penn Station and Central Park if you want a bit of a longer walk. Safe area. I never once felt unsafe anywhere around the hotel. Food and shops - loads of good to go options in the surrounding couple of blocks, especially pizza and bagels. A couple of well stocked supermarkets. Roof terrace - nice terrace which I barely saw anyone using during my stay. Staff - couldn’t fault the staff. Friendly and helpful. Available 24/7. Cons - The entire hotel is tired and shabby looking. Chipped tiles, stained walls, threadbare carpets. The shared bathrooms can be touch and go. I appreciate that with a shared bathroom you rely on the decency of other guests and they can’t be cleaned after every use. On the plus side there are lots of them so I never had to wait. But probably a third of the time other guests hadn’t left them in the best state. Overall I would recommend the hotel on the basis that it’s about as cheap as you can get in Manhattan. Just be aware that this is far from luxury. If you just need somewhere to sleep it’ll do just fine."

"Nice property "

"The property needs better facilities"

"This was a beautiful hotel. There is such a beautiful view of the city. Right off the highway. Very convenient."