This was our first time renting a private villa and we are very happy overall.
PROS: spectacular views, wonderful infinity pool, large rooms, very easy communication with the management, ability to hire transportation and order food, beach is minutes away, quiet environment, total tranquility and relaxation, due to the altitude mosquitoes were not as big of an issue as in the beach resorts,
CONS: not a full service resort with restaurants on premises, housekeeping every second day (if you care about those things, be aware, otherwise those aren't real reasons not to choose this accommodation).
Previously, we used to stay only at the resorts on the island, but now this private villa option is definitely a big contender for the next trip. The views alone are worth it and cannot be matched by any beach resort IMO.
Thank you Jum, Yaya, Jeff and the entire team for making our stay very memorable!