Like: In the center of Front Street. AC cooled well. 203 has a great view and is spacious and reasonably priced. Wifi worked well.
Dislike: Many details in the rooms are unfinished or lack maintenance. e.g. Missing or damaged and dirty lamp coverings and shades, burnt bulbs, poor lighting and not warm light, electrical wiring of AC outside protective casing. Ceiling fan in the bedroom is too low and forms a danger. TV's had no channels. Some mold on the bathroom ceiling. Showerhead was loose, No iron and no iron board. Not convinced that pillowcases were clean, some bathroom towels were stained but smelted clean (looked shabby). No "do not disturb" card. Headboard of bed is loose, electrical receptacles are worn down causing plugs to be loose causing sparks. Broken curtains elements. Former plastic cable coverings stuck on walls and ceilings which are no longer in use.
Some investment and a bit labor to improve relatively small, mentioned details and issues would make a world of difference and create value for the user, the owners and further enhance St. Maarten's touristic product.
I hope this helps to improve.