Pros: Directly across the street from Penn Station, one block from MSG, and has a subway station within feet of the hotel. There was always a canister of fruit infused water greeting us when we returned from our days outing. The breakfast was more than sufficient. The front desk staff tried hard to be helpful
Cons: One elevator was down, which translated to long waits at the elevator- up to 15 minutes as we were on the top floor. I found this on expedia to be an 'excellent' hotel, when we walked in the carpets to the foyer were filthy (both in stains and looked like it needed to be vaccumed badly),the room has a 'governor' on the AC which would not allow it to go below 68.
Overall, I would stay here for the convienence but I would not have set my expectations as high.