Lovely property, lovely grounds, clean well kept room with great views in a beautiful historic building, walkable distance from the Montauk train station. Friendly, helpful staff for the most part. Would stay again.
A few quirks, negatives:
-room smelled musty like an old summer cabin
-no iron in the room and had to go to front desk to retrieve as "everyone is busy"
-they hand over 5 (!) remotes to take up to the room upon checkin and had to gather them together to return upon checkout. (So weird, imo) Could only get one TV to work.
-coffee is unavailable in room or lobby until restaurant opens at 8 a.m. (had a coffeemaker in room but no grounds/filters, byoc)
-have to go to front desk to get key to use exercise room and return upon completion