Do not let the pictures or decent reviews fool you. I was actually literally scared to stay in this hotel and if it hadn't been for the fact that I already paid and couldn't get a refund I would have left. It is falling down (literally, there are pieces of the building falling off of it), it is very shady looking, not well lit, the parking lot is just a bunch of awful potholes one after another, anyone can just walk into any of the doors on the exterior of the building and access the guest room halls, etc. The rooms are nowhere near as nice as the photos make them seem (apparently they redid 1-2 rooms and just took photos of those ones?) plus the rest of the place looks like it's from the 60s with 0 updating.
The water in the shower never got hot (luke warm at best), the breakfast was okay, and the staff was fine - nice, but certainly not warm and welcoming.
The entire place left a terrible taste in my mouth and I just didn't want to be there 100% of the time I was in Ithaca. We actually just stayed out late, high-tailed it to the room because it was so suspicious, and then checked out early and left.